PDFPrint

Sidney does not see the Flushing goldsmith as a key player, but sees him as an honest worker who was not a key mover compared to Baines and Marlowe. Only one coin had been made, and Sidney wrote to Burghley this was almost “with a half eye to be discovered”. Sidney thought the goldsmith was being manipulated by the other two men and possibly Baines had decided to forestall putting forged coin into circulation. Sidney, clearly nonplussed was not willing to take responsibility – the Dutch authorities were already restless at the English sending troops. He understood the barely veiled threat from Marlowe that he was known to the Earl of Northumberland and Lord Strang (Strange) which posed a risk of annoying members of the nobility – so Sidney passed the buck to Lord Burghley, sending Gilbert back to England with Marlowe to be dealt with by the Lord Treasurer.

Once Marlowe and the goldsmith were sent home, the letter has served its purpose, but the
turn of events has its own logic. It is remarkable that historians have generally failed to understand coining carried the death penalty. One who did was Charles Nicholl, who realised coining was a capital offence when he wrote the later version of The Reckoning (2002). In this (30) he quotes the poet Thomas Lodge on coiners in the lines

“When other subtle shifts do fail
They fall to coining, & from thence by course
Through hempen windows learn to shake their tail”.

‘Hempen windows’ means the hangman’s noose. The brutal fact facing Marlowe as he went back to England arrested and probably in chains, was that he faced execution. The most mysterious event of all the mysterious events which happened to him was about to happen. Marlowe was sent back to be interrogated by Burghley – no record of which has been found. It is significant that Nicholl quotes a verbatim interview by Burghley of a Catholic captured at Flushing on 23rd December 1592 some months after Marlowe: Flushing was so important to the English that interrogation by the 70 year old Lord Burghley (31) was a priority. Marlowe could not have escaped interview by the Lord Treasurer, the Queen’s main advisor for over forty years. And then nothing happened: Marlowe is released.

Charles Nicholl, the writer who has done most to probe what happened when the prisoners arrived back in England, records that on the back of the letter there is a docket which records that Marlowe and Gilbert were ‘taken for coinage’ and were sent over ‘to be tried here for that fact’ written by one of Burghley’s secretaries (31 yes 31). who seems to have expected prosecution of an offence carrying a capital charge. This did not happen, though Burghley as chief minister always followed events abroad closely. Nicholl quotes a letter from a Catholic quoting another Catholic Thomas Dawbney, who was brought back from Flushing some months later, and was interrogated by Burghley. It is very likely the Lord Treasurer would interview Marlowe himself, though no evidence of this has been discovered. Charles Nicholl found a warrant for the expenses of David Lloyd, Sidney’s ensign, for bringing letters from Flushing and “three prisoners committed to his charge” (32). Nicholl states that the warrant was signed by Burghley himself.

The implication is that he knew Marlowe was one of the three men sent to England once he had received Sidney’s letter, as the issue of why Marlowe was not prosecuted for forgery lies at the heart of why Marlowe was in Flushing, and whether he was operating as a freelance with a personal (criminal) agenda, or as an approved agent on a government mission – which however was so secret that the garrison commander had not been informed. Unlike the questions that are raised by the Privy Council letter to Cambridge, there is no obvious authorisation by the state: why the secrecy? As with Sherlock Holmes and the Dog that Did Not Bark (33), Burghley’s inaction is a message which speaks volumes. By May Marlowe is tangling with the local constable in Holywell Street in Shoreditch, small beer compared to being excused a capital offence. As would happen with the conflicts two years later which destroyed Kyd, Marlowe was leading a privileged life. Was this because he was still working for the government?