PDFPrint

The Balance Of Probabilities

A final answer to whether Marlowe’s extra curricular activities can be seen as spying cannot be provided on the basis of the evidence currently available. It is clear that he was employed by the government while a student, and on the balance of probabilities his expedition to Flushing was a political not a criminal excursion, as he was breaking the law but was not prosecuted: Burghley released him, but this was an unofficial mission – the garrison commander had no knowledge of why he and the goldsmith had arrived. But the most important lesson of this survey is that if Marlowe had a controller, the name of Lord Burghley comes into focus time and again.

Riggs is perceptive in seeing “When Marlowe appears in government archives he is dealing with Burghley or his agents, not with Walsingham” (50). This observation is true for both the major documents surveyed in this paper. In 1587 Burghley signs the letter to Cambridge. After Flushing Marlowe is sent home to be interrogated by Burghley. Walsingham is not in the frame when decisions have to be made about Christopher Marlowe, but Burghley most certainly is, and his presence suggests a way to cope with the lack of payment dockets for Marlowe’s assignments, and lack of evidence for his activities, both of which could be privately organised. Only research into the private papers of the Cecil family and other archives could test that hypothesis. But it is clear Burghley had heard the name – there is no such certainty with Francis Walsingham who after his death in 1590 had no further part to play anyway. As a controller, Lord Burghley is by far the more plausible candidate. Without more archival research, this remains unproven. It is possible that there was contact with leading politicians after Marlowe received his degree, having proved he was reliable – but reliable in what? What counts as spying?

The service for the Queen and most likely route into payments from the state for a student at Cambridge would be spying on fellow students, and this could be supplemented in his MA years by work as a courier, if he had travel experience and some languages – there being a French exile community in Canterbury he is likely to have some spoken French which would make him employable in the same work as Watson whether or not Watson made the introduction. Watson met Walsingham in Paris,but there is no indication Marlowe ever met Francis Walsingham. The fact that Marlowe survived Flushing does not prove he was successful in the world of espionage – Riggs suggests Burghley kept him back to attempt to penetrate the Stanley conspiracy (51) but his cover had been blown and Honan is right that he had to face “the possibility that he had lost his chances as an agent” (52). Marlowe’s brief career as a spy was over. How important had it been?

It is perhaps most useful to study Marlowe’s activities in comparision with known operators in the murky world of counter-intelligence. The approach of Stephen Alford in his comprehensive study THE WATCHERS (53) surveys the whole range of espionage activities across Elizabeth’s reign. He compares Marlowe with Robert Poley who is undoubtedly a spy – and is unusually long serving in a short lived profession. Poley’s first sighting as a spy is Junw 1585, working for Leicester. The last payment is September 5th 1601, for Robert Cecil. Thus he worked for all three networks including Walsingham’s. Alford’s careful analysis of the data concludes that as an espionage agent Marlowe was hardly a player, but Robert Poley – the fourth man in the room in Deptford – certainly was. He gives Marlowe only 3 index entries but Poley 15- and when he contrasts the two , his verdict is compelling. He argues “Where for Marlowe the evidence of secret service is sketchy and circumstantial, for the unliterary Poley it is overwhelming. There is evidence of 26 missions in 13 years, with Poley having his own ciphers and a secret postal address in Antwerp. And yet “he was a teller of tales, something of a conman and a bully and an accomplished liar… Poley was cunning, mercurial and dangerously persuasive. But perhaps these were precisely the skills his masters needed him to employ… certainly Sir Robert Cecil kept him on the payroll till 1601.” (54) There has never been any doubt Poley was a spy: and he was a very successful one. Marlowe was also a spy, but success escaped him. As a spy he was someone who dabbled, perhaps to earn a little extra income, but when he went beyond courier work, then he was out of his depth. That may be the lesson to be taken from his work at Cambridge and at Flushing.