The attempt to see Marlowe as a spy – someone deeply immersed in the world of espionage is influenced by the notion that spying was glamorous and spiced with danger. The reality was very different and while Marlowe did flirt with danger, he neither had the skills of a Robert Poley to survive in this world nor the ability which Thomas Watson had, to realise when he was out of his depth and move on. Marlowe has come to be seen as logically part of the world of Francis Walsingham because the spycatcher has an aura, so this is held to mean they must have been in contact. The less charismatic William Cecil, Lord Burghley, appears far more regularly in the records as knowing Marlowe. It is time to see Marlowe as Burghley would have seen him, as a technician without glamour delivering on a mission carrying an investment. At Cambridge, Marlowe gave satisfaction and the Privy Council said so. For the last four years of his known life, the story is very different. After Flushing, the 16 months which Kuriyama rightly saw as being so markedly different that they constitute “the apparent shift in his behaviour” (55) can only be understood as Marlowe lived them as someone who had failed as a spy and lived on the edge, increasingly of concern to the authorities.
Yet did he fail in the final analysis? Honan hints that Poley’s mission which covered the Deptford incident is unusual and has a special phrase in the payment warrant saying he was him to take time off while being paid, which Nicholl also noted. Honan goes on to say
“The Cecil’s had evidently requested something special, in all likelihood that he prepare Marlowe for work. A plan to send the poet into Scotland had been mooted: Kyd suggests as much in his final allegation to the Lord Keeper” (56)
Honan is right, Kyd had discussed Marlowe’s willingness to consider going to Scotland where Kyd thought Roydon had gone: Roydon was a friend of Marlowe, who had served on an espionage mission to Prague who had also been bilked by Skeres for the sum of £150. There are unexplored links between Marlowe’s circle and the events at Deptford. What happened to bring Poley and Skeres and Marlowe into the room in Deptford is another topic: but possibly it is the last episode which can be seen as involvement in spying. The cultural significance of Marlowe – which is far from exclusively as a writer – does not lie in the world of espionage. But he was, as many writers in the twentieth century also showed, adept at dabbling in the world of covert activity. In this, Marlowe poses the question less whether he was a spy, but how far a freelance agent with other major interests could take on the role of a spy as and when it was offered to him.
Trevor Fisher 20 9 21
Notes
(1)-Park Honan, Christopher Marlowe, Poet and Spy (Oxford 2005), chapter 5 addresses the issue of covert activities under the heading Espionage.
(2) Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (ODNB) entry on Christopher Marlowe, by Charles Nicholl, 3rd January 2008. Section on “Government service c1585-87”- both the statement and the dates are questionable.
(3) ODND entry on Sir Francis Walsingham, Simon Adams, Alan Bryson and Mitchell Leimon, 21st May 2009.
(4) Hotson’s pamphlet was Death of Christopher Marlowe, J Leslie Hotson, London Nonsuch Press, Cambridge (USA) Harvard University Press, 1925
(5) Hotson, op cit, p67.
(6) Eugenie de Kalb, a graduate student studying Marlowe at Cambridge, in the Times Literary Supplement for May 21st 1925 reviewed the Hotson analysis of the events involving Marlowe in Deptford on May 30th 1593,– two months after Leslie Hotson had published – criticised the Coroner’s inquest and made connections between three men in the room and covert activities, in her view only the alleged killer Ingram Frizer was not a spy.
(7) David Riggs The World of Christopher Marlowe Faber and Faber (2004) states Skeres was a bit player in the Babington Conspiracy on p152.
(8) Charles Nicholl The Reckoning pp36-37 Vintage Books Revised edition 2002~
(9) The letter was discovered by R B Wernham and first published, with a critique, in the English Historical Review (1976) Vol 91 pp344-5 – Nicholl 2002 states in the uncatalogued recesses of the SP84 state papers Holland in the PRO. P279
(10) Alison Plowden, The Elizabethan Secret Service, Harvester Wheatsheaf, St Martin’s Press 1991
(11) Honan 2005 pp121- 122. He then discusses the Walsingham operation. pp122-130 arguing Marlowe worked for Walsingham(12) Honan 2005 p270. Quotes Philby My Silent War 1968 p154
(13) According to Alan Haynes Invisible Power Alan Sutton 1992 p97 in September 1592 Robert Poley went “twice through Canterbury at a time when Marlowe and Paul Ivey, the fortifications engineer and periodic intelligencer (ie spy TF) were both in the town”. Poley was an established, full time agent, Marlowe and Ivey had other strings to their financial bow but were willing to handle secret communications. Marlowe is not known to have met Poley at this time. Reilly Prince of Spies is a novelistic take on the career of Sidney Reilly, the real life model for Bond.
(14) Susan Doran Elizabeth’s Circle 2015-18 p270. (15) Honan on payment p127
(16) Mark Eccles Christopher Marlowe in London, Harvard 1934, Octagon New York 1967, p4.
(17) Riggs op cit p152- Riggs also alleges the Baines note itemised Marlowe’s ‘crimes’
(18) Kuriyama op cit p3 (19) John Cooper, The Queen’s Agent, Francis Walsingham at the Court of Elizabeth 1, Faber & Faber 2012, p179\
(20) Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, entry on Stephen Gosson, Arthur F Kinney(21) Appendix A- given by Francis Brown Kuriyama in Christopher Marlowe, a Renaissance Life, Cornell 2010 pp202-03, from the Acts of the Privy Council.
(22) David Riggs, 2004 op cit p130
(23) Peter R Roberts, Christopher Marlowe at Corpus, IN Pelican The magazine of Corpus Christi College Cambridge, issue 26 – Easter 2014 p28
(24) C F Tucker Brooke, The Life of Marlowe and the Tragedy of Dido Queen of Carthage, London 1933 p20
(25) Constance Brown Kuriyama Christopher Marlowe, A Renaissance Life Cornell 2010 p7
(26) Austin K Gray, Some Observations on Christopher Marlowe, Government Agent, FMLA Sep 1928, Vol 43, No 3, pp682-700. Published by the Modern Language Association. Read is drawn in though his studies of Walsingham had no connection with Marlowe.
(27) Roy Kendall Christopher Marlowe & Richard Baines, Journeys through the Elizabethan Underworld, Farleigh Dickinson University Press, 2004. David Riggs op cit 130-138 and Kuriyama 2002, pp64-69
(28) Honan 2005 pp241-2. Honan argues money was drying up, especially from Thomas Walsingham.
(29) Nicholl 2002 p281
(30) Nicholl 2002 p283 Poem A fig for Momus
(31) Nicholl 2002 p284
(32) Nicholl 2002 p285
(33) The quote is from the Sherlock Holmes story The Adventure of the Silver Blaze. The crucial passage is “Is there any other point to which you would wish to draw my attention?” “To the curious incident of the dog in the night time”. “The dog did nothing in the night time”. “That is the curious incident”. (34) Nicholl ODNB 2008 section Government Service c1585-1587 Nicholls cites 1585 as the year working for the Queen began. On what evidence?
(35) Honan 2005 p147 “The fact his payments were not recorded indicates what he did was secretive… … dire lack of couriers.. signs he was in France and the lowlands” What signs?
OMIT Nicholl p278 NOTE EXCELLENT DESCRIPTION OF TOWN IN WAR
(36) Alford, Stephen The Watchers, Allan Lane 2012, p317
(37) Alford, Some Elizabethan Spies in the Office of Sir Francis Walsingham, IN Diplomacy and Modern Culture, ed Robyn Adams & Rosanna Cox, Palgrave Macmillan 2011 p48
(38) Honan 2005 pp241-242
(39) For Stanley’s mission see Nicholl 2002 pp273-277
(40) Nicholl, ODNB entry on Marlowe, 2008
(41) Alford 2011page 53.
(42) Nicholl, 2002 p294
(43) Nicholl 2002 p281
(44) Kuriyama 2002 p108
(45) Honan 2005 pp269-270
(46) Honan 2005 p271
(47) Riggs 2004 pp 273-279 gives the episode in full
(48) Riggs 2004 p277
(49) Riggs 2004 p279
(50) Riggs 2004 p181
(51) Riggs 2004 p279
(52) Honan 2005 p281
(53) Stephen Alford, The Watchers, A secret history of the reign of Elizabeth 1, Allen Lane 2012, Penguin 2013(54) Alford op cit p317
(55) Kuriyama 2002 p3
(56) Honan 2005 p345